By Douglas P. Lackey, Ph.D.
In recent months, Britain, France, Australia, and Canada have “recognized” a Palestinian state. The announcement was greeted with great enthusiasm by two or three people. Most of the rest of us ignored the announcements, and rightly so. I have heard talk about a Palestinian state almost every day since 1967. Nothing ever comes of it, and the prospects today seem worse than ever. Talk of Palestinian statehood has become a way to kick the can down the road, a self-congratulatory route to continuing the status quo. The Palestinian state is a mirage, that forever recedes the moment it is approached.
The reason for current long odds on a Palestinian state is that the people who live in the region don’t want one. The Israeli government is furiously set against it. Polls in Israeli show that a majority of the population opposes it. The thinking is simple: the Palestinians had a Palestinian state, populated by Palestinians and run by Palestinians. It was called Gaza. What is to prevent the next Palestinian state from following a similar course, seized by radicals who have no other thought than the destruction of Israel, and who count mass murder as an acceptable means to achieve their ends?
Furthermore, I think the Palestinians themselves don’t want a Palestinian state, as the quid pro quo for such a state has always been a recognition of the legitimacy of Israel. It is not hard to understand why people who have seen their helpless relatives killed on a daily basis have difficulty considering the perpetrators of these killings and their government as legitimate actors on the world stage.
The time has come for a new approach, focused on people and not on statehood. What is it that individual Palestinians living in the West Bank or in Gaza, really need? Physical security most of all, economic security with decent jobs, and basic legal security under a system of law. Palestinians, for example, need to be able to sue for damages when their property is destroyed and to expect justice when they are the victims of crimes.
Physical, economic, and legal security can exist only if backed by the power of a state, which provides these securities in the form of citizenship. It is citizenship that Palestinians need, and the only state from which they can get it is the state which has power over the place that they live, the state of Israel. The hidden remedy, then, for this endless conflict is Israeli citizenship for Palestinian people.
The proposal is radical. It assumes that the geographical territories of the West Bank and Gaza will be incorporated into the State of Israel. The Israeli right will get its Greater Israel. In return, the inhabitants of the West Bank and Gaza are to be granted full citizenship, except in such cases of persons who have committed violent crimes or acts against the Israel state. Without hesitation, all Palestinian children should immediately obtain full citizenship.
Once the Palestinians realize that their security is guaranteed by the Israeli government, they will recognize that they have a stake in the survival of Israel, that a life-long commitment to the destruction of Israel is opposed to the security of themselves and their families. They will have the right to vote, and they will participate in the democratic process. One legislative problem will require special adjudication: Land claims of Palestinians dating back to 1948. If claims cannot be implemented, compensation is due.
One might argue that the odds are small that the Israelis will make a move in this direction. Perhaps so, but the odds that they will move towards a Palestinian state are smaller still. Indeed, with so many non-Jewish citizens, and with legal guarantees irrespective of race or religion, Israel would no longer be a Jewish state. But it would still be a state for Jews, as there is no reason under this proposal to revoke the Law of Return.
A state for Jews which incorporates a substantial minority of non-Jewish citizens may seem like an abandonment of the Zionist ideal. But Martin Buber devoted his long life to Zionism, and never advocated for a Jewish state. Buber wanted a bi-national state, and the present proposal runs largely parallel to his. As a philosopher who has long admired Buber, I am happy to endorse his version of the cause.
Douglas Lackey is Professor of Philosophy at Baruch College and the Graduate Center, CUNY.
Photo by Levi Meir Clancy on Unsplash